“What books do you suggest I read to learn more about the history of musical theatre and how different composers and librettists work together?” I asked one evening, as a resident graduate of NYU’s MFA program in musical theatre and another resident working on a novel joined me on the porch to enjoy the sunset.
“One of my favorites books,” responded the musical theatre resident, “is called Putting It Together: How Stephen Sondheim and I Created Sunday in the Park with George. And I can email you the reading list that students get from NYU when they are accepted into the program.”
She did indeed email me the list, entitled “Year 1 Textbooks & Summer Reading/Listening.” It is an extensive and challenging reading list. It begins with their required textbook: American Musicals: The Complete Books and Lyrics of 16 Broadway Classics, 1927-1969 (Library of America) by Laurence Maslon. I was really pleased to see how many of the musicals in their textbook I had seen and enjoyed. If you remember from the last blog, as a youngster I danced to the original cast albums in my friend’s living room. Today there are quite a few I listen to while I am walking/dancing in the swimming pool. I am surprised to see that well over 75% of the sixteen musicals are favorites of mine and I know most of the words of the songs. Check this link and press “more” to see the names of the 16 musicals that are included in the two-volume set.
The required reading goes on to list 42 more current musical theatre works with which the student should be familiar, and again I have seen many of them. But there are some I haven’t seen, and so I am building my own list of what I need to listen to, read or see if I can find them on YouTube. Next there is a list of 50 plays the faculty recommends, as they feel musical theatre has often been lacking in diversity. I hunch I won’t spend much time going over this list although I applaud the program for wanting future musical theatre writers to be familiar with these works. The last section intrigues me as it continues with books on the writing and process of creating a musical theatre work. WHEW… so if I get bored I have a lot of resources to go to in a field I am passionate about.
The resident novelist also responded to my question and made a super suggestion, “Read Mary Rodgers’ Shy: The Alarming Outspoken Memoirs of Mary Rodgers.
I didn’t know much about Mary Rodgers other than her being the daughter of Richard Rodgers of Rodgers and Hammerstein fame. My curiosity was piqued and so I downloaded the audio book written by Mary Rodgers and Jesse Green. The book had me laughing from the very beginning. She immediately lets you know that Richard Rodgers was no saint. When someone is identified by the narrator Christine Baranski (who is reading Mary’s voice), Jesse Green gives us immediate notes about the person. For Richard Rodgers, Jesse states, “1902 – 1979, composer, womanizer, alcoholic, genius.” The main game Richard Rodgers played with his two daughters was getting them to identify musical intervals. That’s ear training, which is part of college composition courses. The girls loved it and his reaction when they got it right. The first chapter, called “Hostility,” goes on to name a variety of games that Mary played with various people in her life, most of whose names are very familiar if you are a musical theatre person. Among her close friends was Stephen Sondheim, and he figures a lot in the narrative.
It was a quick listen as the book continues with a sense of humor, sarcasm and inside scoop on what the musical theatre royalty celebrities’ life was like. It was great fun for me, and I learned some interesting things about Mary Rodgers, a writer/composer herself. Even though she was married two times and had three children with each husband, she was the main support of her family. She faced many challenges as a woman in the mainly male-oriented musical theatre writing and composing world.
Among her unique jobs was writing songs for the Little Golden Books for children, and assisting the producer for Leonard Bernstein’s Young People’s Concerts which were television specials from 1958 – 1972. She wrote the novel Freaky Friday in 1972, and it has had a long life of entertaining people with the playful situation of a mom and daughter switching places for a day. Disney has made three films with the name and story outline. The first one was in 1977 and starred Jodie Foster as Annabelle the daughter and Barbara Harris as the mother. It tickled me to see how the Disney channel describes each of the four movies just a bit differently.
For the 1977 version the description is, “A free-spirited girl switches bodies with her strait-laced mother.” When they remade the film, released in 2003, it starred Lindsay Lohan as Anna the daughter and Jamie Lee Curtis as the mom and was then described as, “A mother and daughter see things a bit differently when they switch bodies.” I watched the 2003 film and it was a perfect antidote to the day’s news. Fast forward to 2018 and now it’s “Disney’s madcap musical teen Ellie and Mom Katherine swap bodies” starring Cozi Zuehlsdorff as Ellie and Heidi Blickenstaff as the mom.
Next time I need a funny cheer-me-up from the day’s headlines I will watch one of the other interpretations. And I can look forward to one that is soon to be released by Disney called Freakier Friday which is being billed as the sequel to the 2003 film version.
I’m fascinated by how Mary Rodgers’ novel has motivated different interpretations, and I look forward to watching all the films and comparing them with the original 1977 which is probably closest to the book. In fact, as a beginning writer, curious about how something is adapted to theater or film, reading the actual novel sounds appropriate.
Until reading Shy I mainly knew Mary Rodgers as composer for Once Upon a Mattress. I was lucky to see the show, which starred Carol Burnett, in 1959. I was taken to see it by my father’s elderly great-aunt and uncle, who lived in NYC when I was taking a modern dance intensive at the Martha Graham Studio. I had to pass up my favorite habit of waiting at the stage door to get autographs. While the show didn’t have a long run (256 performances) it is still frequently performed by community and school groups across the United States, and a Google search proved just how popular the show has been.
On YouTube you can watch two made-for-television productions, both starring Carol Burnett, one made in 1964 and the other in 1972. In 2024 Sutton Foster played the Carol Burnett role of Princess Winnifred on Broadway, and in fact opening on July 16th there is a production at Central City Opera in Central City, Colorado. Indeed, as Mary stated in her book, there is always a production of Once Upon a Mattress playing somewhere. Next time I am looking for something to dance to in the pool, it will be the original cast album of Once Upon a Mattress available on YouTube.
I highly recommend Shy for the inside story on famous people in the musical theatre world during the 40’s through 60’s. It was also valuable to learn how shows are developed and how Mary Rodgers persevered as a woman competing in a male-dominated career. I love that her work continues to have a presence in the entertainment world today, over 50 years later.

Book Cover
Next blog will be a look at Putting It Together: How Stephen Sondheim and I Created Sunday in the Park with George by James Lapine. Meanwhile if you have seen Once Upon a Mattress or Freaky Friday I would love to hear your thoughts! And of course, if you have read Shy, please share too.























